Welcome to another blog post!
If you’ve been following my blog for a while, you’ll know I do have a fascination about true crime. I’m always that person that consumes different true crime media, from documentaries and podcasts to various true crime youtubers.
However, since I wrote a blog post about the ethics of true crime content, I’ve started to look at true crime content differently. In that post, I looked at the ethics surrounding true crime content from a generic point of view. That’s easy to do. What about me though? Have I changed? Let’s talk about it!
Being Too Comfortable With True Crime
If I’m honest, I would say that I was a little too comfortable with true crime. That’s not to say that I think it’s suddenly completely wrong to consume true crime. I still find it fascinating. I still want to know why certain people decide to do illegal things, whether it be murder/drug offences etc. The problem is, it’s easy to consume true crime.
Think about it. You can easily find a documentary on any streaming site about any true crime case. True crime podcasts and YouTubers are absolutely everywhere and short-form posts on TikTok and Instagram can explain a murder case in 60 seconds. It’s become normal and that’s what I find uncomfortable.
At the end of the day, the people involved are not fictional characters. They are real humans. Everything that we see on these shows or listen to on podcasts happened to real people. We spend an hour to two hours consuming true crime content and all the bad things that happened but for those involved, those bad things stick with them for the rest of their lives. That’s something that I’m much more conscious about.
The Victims Are Starting to Become Afterthoughts
This is something that is really starting to frustrate me. I’ve noticed that the attention seems to be much more on the perpetrator than the actual victim or victims involved. We end up learning their name, we see their face, learn about their childhood, relationships and anything that’s built up to them committing the offence.
Sometimes we know more about the perpetrator than the victim and that should not be the case. It really annoys me when certain things I watch have this disclaimer at the beginning that says something like ‘there’s more of a focus on the victim than the perpetrators here’ when it is really obvious the perpetrator is the main focus.
Is understanding a perpetrator and their motivations important? Sure. After all, understanding why something happened can help us to prevent similar things from happening in the future. The problem is I feel we’re becoming too fascinated by the wrong person if that makes sense.
I’m Becoming Picky About What I Watch
Will I stop watching true crime? No. At the same time, I don’t think I’ve got a perfect way to consume it ethically in the way that I want to. All I can say is I have become way more selective.
I have noticed this with the true crime YouTubers I choose to watch. There are certain people that I used to love watching back in the day but as I’ve become older and more aware, I’m not subscribed and I don’t watch them anymore. I hate the unnecessary sensationalism with certain YouTubers. I look at the way things are structured. Do they do their sponsors at the beginning or push it in halfway through when it makes no sense? I don’t have the answer on what is perfect but there are certain people I gravitate to who do genuinely good things.
Documentaries are also something I’m selective about. This has mainly come about this year though. I don’t know if you all remember that Lucy Letby documentary that came out on Netflix. I watched it and I said to myself that I would never watch a documentary with that much justified criticism again. I could talk about AI within media in another blog post so let me know if that is something you would like to see.
But, There is Nothing Wrong With Being Curious
Of course, I do not want this post to come across as me saying that anyone who enjoys true crime is insensitive. I still enjoy true crime. I’m curious about it. At the end of the day, society has always had a fascination with crime since the dawn of time. It’s natural to be interested in things we don’t understand, in things that are frightening or in things that are unusual.
Indeed, I also think there are genuinely valuable things that can come from true crime content. I’ve studied law for four years, so I’m aware of the failures within the justice system. True crime content can bring awareness to cases that really need it.
I guess what I’m trying to say is having a fascination with true crime is not a bad thing. But, I am changing how I view it.
And that’s it! Thank you so much for taking the time out of your day to read this post and I will see you soon for another one!
Beth

Great post! The only time period of my life where I’ve ever really consumed a lot of true crime content was when I was a teenager, and I’d say that was more accidental consumption rather than intentional. As an IB student in high school with severe ADHD, I often found myself staying awake into the early hours of the morning to complete homework, and I’d keep the TV on to have some continuous background noise to help keep me awake. Turns out that most TV stations run their true crime TV series in the middle of the night (or, at least in the 2010s they did, lol), so, naturally, I’d end up at the very least listening to those shows, if not actually watching them. In some ways, I get the fascination with true crime, although as a Marxist and an anthropologist-in-training, I see that content as “problematic” from a decolonial, feminist, Marxist lens in that it can easily fall into “copaganda” by convincing people that our (the US) justice system only needs reform, rather than needing to be torn down and replaced with a system which is far more invested in community care, crime prevention, and restorative justice. There’s also the added layer that, historically forensic “science” was often racialized bunk “science” that had no basis in reality and was often used to justify racial profiling (and I say that as someone who is training to become a forensic anthropologist). Which is…not necessarily what true crime content might have you believe about the validity of forensic evidence. I don’t consume true crime content anymore for a myriad of reasons, including the reasons you mentioned in your post and the reasons I just mentioned, but I definitely don’t fault people for their curiosity. I think that maybe a way to be a more ethical consumer of true crime content starts with interrogating your reasons for being interested in it and your reasons for being most interested in whichever aspect of the “story” that you are fascinated by.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for such a lovely comment! I agree entirely.
LikeLiked by 1 person